College football is apparently heading toward another playoff expansion, this time from 12 teams to 24. A huge jump for sure, but was anyone really asking for this? Of course, we know why it’s happening — more games mean more television revenue, advertising, and opportunities to make a lot more money. But while the financial benefits are obvious, I wonder whether anyone is seriously considering what college football is losing along the way?

For those of us who have loved college football for decades, there’s something increasingly sad about watching the sport change so dramatically of late. College football once had a very unique quality that made it different from almost every other sport: Every game seemed to matter. A September upset could, and often did, destroy national championship aspirations. A November rivalry was a game circled on the schedule a year in advance and could define an entire season. Sometimes a single loss was enough to change the college football landscape.
That uncertainty created extraordinary anticipation. Saturdays weren’t simply opportunities to watch football games, they were annual events with enormous emotional consequences.
Now think about a new, 24-team playoff. A powerhouse school loses two games, perhaps even three, and still makes the postseason. A highly anticipated rivalry ends in defeat, but both teams advance anyway. The games still count, of course, but do they carry the same weight?
Psychologically, part of what makes an experience special is its scarcity. When opportunities are limited, we tend to value them more. When something becomes increasingly available, even extraordinary experiences (i.e. two storied college football programs playing) can gradually feel ordinary. College football seems determined to test that principle.
We now have more postseason opportunities, more nationally televised games, and more playoff football than ever before. Yet I wonder whether all that additional football is making the sport more exciting — or simply making it more routine?
There’s also the concern of fan fatigue. People have limited time, attention, and emotional energy. When nearly every weekend offers another supposedly monumental matchup, how long before the word monumental loses its meaning? Can every game really be the greatest game ever?!
Even sports gambling adds an interesting wrinkle. More playoff games mean more opportunities to wager, and a relatively unremarkable matchup can suddenly feel important when money is riding on the outcome. But there’s something troubling about that distinction. College football once made games meaningful because of what was at stake on the field. Increasingly, we’re finding other ways to manufacture that excitement.
So here we are now with a 24 team playoff system that looks far different from the original BCS era of just two teams, or even the 4-team and current 12-team playoff model. More teams, but also more potential changes — and not all will be welcome changes. Another conference realignment. Another expanded playoff. Another disrupted rivalry. Another tradition quietly disappearing.
Fans complain, but eventually will adjust. We continue watching because we love our schools, our teams, and the personal memories associated with them. But adapting to something doesn’t necessarily mean embracing it, and continuing to watch doesn’t necessarily mean enjoying it as much as we once did.

Final thoughts
Maybe the saddest part of college football’s endless expansion isn’t that the people running the sport have forgotten what made it special — it’s that the fans haven’t. Fans remember when a Saturday afternoon could make or break a season, when a rivalry loss could haunt the program for a year, and when competing for a national championship was truly extraordinary. Fans will probably keep watching, cheering, and remembering what college football used to feel like even as the playoffs expand and regular season games essentially meaningless, but it would be nice to see some decision-makers weigh factors beyond added revenue when messing with an established good thing.
drstankovich.com