When most people hear the word hazing, certain images immediately come to mind: forced drinking, paddling, dangerous physical challenges, sleep deprivation, or some humiliating initiation ritual. Those examples are easy, as few people would struggle to identify them as hazing. But what about when hazing doesn’t look like hazing, as with the extreme measures just listed? There are countless examples of situations that seem safe and harmless, but would actually meet the criteria for hazing — and also leave individuals in harms way, or worse yet, in life-threatening situations.

The nuance with hazing
Group initiation efforts can quickly go from something funny to something awkward, embarrassing, and/or dangerous very quickly — and often without much warning. For example, consider a relatively shy freshman athlete who is required to stand in front of the team and sing an embarrassing song. The team laughs, and the freshman laughs too. Nobody physically forced him to participate, and he could have easily refused.
Or could he?
What if this already shy and anxious kid refused to sing, and suddenly was labeled soft by his teammates? What if every freshman before him had sung, but he is the only one who refused? What if the team captains were watching, what would they say or do to a freshman not willing to be a part of team traditions? What if he believed backing out might affect how teammates viewed him? Suddenly, “choice” becomes considerably more complicated.
The reality is that a child who struggles with anxiety may feel compelled to participate due to team pressure, even when the experience causes significant distress and takes a serious toll on their mental health. Could the kid have walked out? Yes, but clearly there is a price to pay for non-compliance when it comes to team traditions, conformity, and acceptance.
One useful contemporary way of thinking about hazing is to focus less exclusively on the behavior and more on the social conditions surrounding it. StopHazing, for example, defines hazing as activities expected of someone joining or participating in a group that humiliate, degrade, abuse, or endanger them — regardless of their willingness to participate.
That last part is important, as often with hazing it is the appearance of participant willingness that provides a false reality of the situation, and is often the precursor to potentially dangerous group dynamics, rituals, and behaviors. “It seemed like he was cool with it, he never said no, and went along with the stunt. How could that be hazing?” Ironically, it is precisely these types of situations that are often the most dangerous!
Sports teams are extraordinarily powerful, tight-knit social groups. Team members dress alike, practice together, travel together, win and lose together, and develop their own traditions, hierarchies and identities. For a young athlete, belonging to that group can become enormously important — important enough to do just about anything to join.
The impact of group dynamics
Psychologists have understood the power of groups for decades, and the findings are very applicable to today’s sports hazing. In Solomon Asch’s famous conformity experiments, participants sometimes publicly gave obviously incorrect answers about the lengths of lines after hearing other members of the group unanimously give the wrong answer. Check out the video below to see firsthand the power of the group on an individual’s decision making:
Another famous psychology study illustrating the impact of an authority figure on an individual’s thinking and behavior is the Stanley Milgram’s obedience experiments. Milgram demonstrated something even more alarming than a person selecting the wrong sized line: ordinary people could be persuaded by an authority figure to continue what they believed were increasingly dangerous electric shocks to another person. In one of the most famous — and controversial — psychology experiments (deemed unethical today), subjects in Milgram’s study exercised behaviors they never thought they would as seen in the video below:
Although neither the Asch nor Milgram studies examined hazing, both reveal something critically important about it: groups can exert tremendous psychological influence on both the people carrying out the behavior and the person expected to endure it. The reality is that we think and act differently in groups compared to when we are alone, and it is the unintended (and often unexpected) group dynamics that emerge and lead to different outcomes than what was expected.
Imagine being a 14-year-old freshman surrounded by older teammates saying, Relax, this is what every new team member does. The psychological question isn’t simply whether that athlete can say “no,” it’s what he believes will happen if he does.
That brings us to something frequently overlooked in discussions about hazing: the contingency. If you participate, you gain acceptance, status, belonging, or simply avoid embarrassment. If you refuse, you risk ridicule, rejection, exclusion, or being perceived as weak. These things don’t even need to be said as it is widely known by kids targeted for hazing that these are the results based on how the kid decides.
Remember, hazing does not have to require physical violence. It might involve humiliating nicknames, degrading language, forced performances, rookie duties, embarrassing disclosures, required clothing, or traditions that appear relatively harmless to outsiders. The behavior matters, but so does the power structure surrounding it.
There is another fascinating group phenomenon at work. Imagine 15 teammates watching a kid go through something uncomfortable. Twelve kids privately think, This is getting ridiculous. Yet, nobody says anything. Each kid looks around, sees nobody objecting, and concludes that everyone else must be comfortable with what is happening. Silence, consequently, becomes evidence of approval.
Over time, often year-to-year for sports teams, hazing can become self-perpetuating: We went through it. We survived. Now it’s your turn.

Final thoughts
Perhaps we need to move beyond thinking about hazing simply as bad people forcing unwilling victims to do terrible things. Sometimes the psychology is much more subtle and nuanced in nature. Kids on a team want to belong, and they don’t want to look weak. Kids will often laugh while feeling humiliated, and participate while wishing they didn’t have to. None of these reactions and behaviors suggest that hazing is good, healthy, or safe, but instead strong evidence to support psychology research showing things like how different we act/react in group settings, the willingness of individuals to be victimized by hazing in order to be part of the team, and how compliance does not mean that the victim wants to go through hazing. When being a part of a team is contingent on kids doing things they shouldn’t or wouldn’t do, the risks of mental and/or physical harm spikes dramatically. As you can see, hazing practices are sometimes quite subtle, but even things that seem innocuous can quickly lead to devastating consequences.
drstankovich.com