Write your search in the input below and press enter.
Esc to close.

The Sports Doc Chalk Talk with Dr. Chris Stankovich

Peak Performance:
Not Just for Sports, for Life

  • Products
    • Toolkits
    • Audio
    • Videos
    • Books
    • Apps
  • Services
  • Chalk Talk
    • Recent
    • Athletes
    • Coaching
    • Sports Parenting
    • Sports Administrators
    • Life
    • Administrators
  • About Dr. Stankovich
  • Testimonials
  • Contact
  • Products
    • Toolkits
    • Audio
    • Books
    • Videos
    • Apps
  • Services
  • Chalk Talk
  • About Dr. Stankovich
  • Testimonials
  • Contact

Hello. Sign In

My Account
  • Login
  • Register
0
The Sports Doc Chalk Talk
Subscribe
The Sports Doc Chalk Talk with Dr. Chris Stankovich
  • Recent
  • Athletes
  • Coaching
  • Sports Parenting
  • Life
  • Administrators
Home / Blog / Examining the Sport Participation Trophy Debate

Examining the Sport Participation Trophy Debate

By: Dr. Chris Stankovich | @DrStankovich | Aug 11, 2021

No Comments

If you are around youth and interscholastic sports, there’s a good chance you have been involved in discussions relating to various general philosophical approaches to how sports should be run in your community and/or school.  During the pandemic, for example, focus has been on how to create safe sport experiences for kids that involve masking, distancing, and regularly sanitizing equipment.  A more general (and less dangerous subject by comparison) discussion is has been around longer than pandemic debates has to do with how to recognize and reward kids who play sports — some have referred to this as the “participation trophy debate.”  Are kids exposed to stress and mental illness by receiving a small ribbon or certificate for simply being on the team?  Critics of leagues providing nominal participation award to kids argue it makes kids “soft,” and prevents kids from working hard since they know they will be rewarded for not even trying.  As a mental health clinician who treats kids regularly, I see this position as not having much merit, as I have yet to assist a kid who has been psychologically damaged in any way for receiving a participation award.  Still, this is a robust debate that has been around for years now, and is still worthy of deeper examination and discussion.

Understanding participation awards

Simply speaking, a participation award in youth sports is a small token recognition given to all kids who successfully complete a sport season.  These kids do not have to have actually accomplished anything on the field/court, and in fact, many of these recipients have barely seen the field of play (and some haven’t played at all).  While critics argue that participation awards soften kids, what is often missing in their analyses are all the things these kids do that often goes unnoticed.  For example, in order to successfully complete a sport season, all kids — including reserves — have to attend and participate in practices; battle through aches, pains, and injuries; and balance sport responsibilities with other commitments in life — like school.  Sure, these kids may not be stars on the field, but they are still held accountable for adhering to all team rules and carrying themselves with integrity and living as role models to their peers.  In fact, when you consider all that reserve kids do while on a team without getting playing time and related recognition, a strong argument can be made that participation trophies undersell the value of these unsung heroes. 

While there is often an immediate gruff you hear when mentioning participation awards, I believe when critics think longer and deeper about all that goes into completing a sport season — especially one where the kid never sees the field — only then can you begin to see the value of recognizing kids trying their best while working to earn playing time.  When we offer small measures of positive reinforcement, it helps kids in many ways, including the following:

  • It helps kids gain a sense of identity as a legitimate team member.
  • It helps kids develop self-esteem and confidence.
  • It helps kids galvanize their resiliency and remain motivated and focused for future success.
  • It’s arguably the simplest way to let kids know that while your time has not yet come, we believe in you, and by persevering you will one day reach your personal sport goals.

Final thoughts

No, from my experience participation awards and trophies don’t turn kids into soft mush, incapable of working hard and achieving future success.  In fact, the opposite often occurs — that is, more kids feel a true part of the team for a simple recognition, and this feeling is often what propels them to continue working hard and eventually earning a position that warrants more playing time.  When we set the sarcasm aside and refrain from using derogatory expressions toward coaches and schools who provide participation awards, only then can we see that critics have blown this discussion out of proportion and created myths that simply do not hold up.

drstankovich.com

athletes, participation, psychology, trophy

  • Author
  • Comments
  • Details
Get to Know the Author

Dr. Chris Stankovich

Dr. Stankovich has written/co-written five books, including Positive Transitions for Student Athletes, The ParentsPlaybook, Mind of Steel.

Latest Blog Posts

  • May 6, 2025 Beyond the Numbers: How Overusing Sport Analytics Can Undermine Expert Judgment
  • April 21, 2025 Juggling Sports and Schedules: The Hidden Costs of Playing Multiple Sports
  • April 17, 2025 Earning Power: College Athletes Aren’t Greedy, They’re Just No Longer Free Labor
  • April 16, 2025 Decoding Intuition: What Happens When We Follow Our Inner Compass?
  • April 8, 2025 Precision, Purpose, Performance: The Psychology of Efficiency in Success

PREVIOUS POST

Sports Parenting Tips for Maximum Sport (and Life) Results

NEXT POST

We versus Them: Examining the Psychology of Fan Behavior

Category

Athletes , Coaching , Emotional Intelligence , health psychology , Leadership and Role Modeling , League Operator , mental health , Sport Philosophy , Sport Psychology , Sport Sociology , Uncategorized , Youth Sports

Tags

athletes, participation, psychology, trophy

  • Recent Posts
  • Most Read
  • Beyond the Numbers: How Overusing Sport Analytics Can Undermine Expert Judgment
  • Juggling Sports and Schedules: The Hidden Costs of Playing Multiple Sports
  • Earning Power: College Athletes Aren’t Greedy, They’re Just No Longer Free Labor
  • Decoding Intuition: What Happens When We Follow Our Inner Compass?
  • Precision, Purpose, Performance: The Psychology of Efficiency in Success
  • The Importance of Passion & Purpose for Sport Success
  • How Human Arousal Impacts Sport Performance
  • Bouncing Back: How Coaches Can Help Kids Learn from a Tough Loss
  • Learn Sports Fear Reduction with these 5 Psychology Tips
  • Why Does Your Kid Play Great in Practice, but Not in Games?
  • The Sports Doc on TV

    Catch Dr. Stankovich’s tv, radio, and print interviews and columns here!

    Dr. Chris Stankovich Watch Videos
  • Sport Performance Assessment

    Dr. Chris Stankovich Quickly and accurately test your level of mental toughness in just a few minutes using the Sport Performance Assessment.

    (SPA), an easy-to-use sport psychology system specially designed to help you REACH YOUR FULL ATHLETIC POTENTIAL.

    learn more
  • SportsSuccess360

    Life strategies for performance and character development for coaches, parents, and student athletes competing in youth and interscholastic sports.

    Life Strategies learn more
  • Contact Dr. Stankovich

    1207 Grandview Ave., Suite #218, Columbus, OH 43212

    (614) 561-4482

    Media & General Inquiries

    information@drstankovich.com

    Sales & Product Support

    sales@drstankovich.com

  • About Dr. Stankovich

    • Media
    • Blog
    • Testimonials
  • Products

    • Toolkits
    • Videos
    • Books
    • Audio
    • iPhone Apps
  • Services

    • Athlete Performance Training
    • Parent Community Forum
    • Coach Education & Development
    • Athletic Crisis Response and Intervention
    • Drug & Alcohol Assessment
    • Life Success Programs
    • Counseling & Consulting Services
  • Blog
  • YouTube
  • twitter
  • facebook

All rights reserved © 2025 Advanced Human Performance Systems™

↓ ↓